Chevron icon It indicates an expandable section or menu, or sometimes previous / next navigation options. HOMEPAGE

CNBC's Rick Santelli Had His Biggest On-Air Blowup In A Long Time, And It Ended With Him Walking Off Air

Santelli Yelling
CNBC

Rick Santelli had a meltdown on CNBC today.

Advertisement

During CNBC's "Fast Money Halftime Report," CNBC reporters Rick Santelli and Steve Liesman, as well as the members of CNBC's Halftime Report panel, went at it over Fed policy.

Santelli has long been critical of the Fed policy, especially its post-financial crisis interest rate policy and large-scale asset purchases, or QE. Liesman is CNBC's resident Fed watcher.

Santelli, who Glenn Beck credited with starting the modern-day Tea Party, sees the Fed's current policies as obstructing economic growth and hampering financial markets. In general, Santelli sees it as the market's responsibility, not the Federal Reserve or the government's job, to sort out economic problems.

The segment is based around the question, "Is the Fed behind the curve?" In short, is the Fed keeping interest rates below where inflation might otherwise dictate. Liesman, we should note, said that the Fed's policy is to be behind the curve.

Advertisement

Things really start to get heated at about the 3:00 minute mark in the clip below after Liesman begins talking about how the market could express its concern that the Fed is behind the curve.

Liesman1
CNBC

To this, Santelli said that of course there wouldn't be any market signs because the Fed's policy has created, "a managed setting," adding that the Fed's policies have, "deprived the markets of hissy fits."

This debate is sparked by the New Yorker profile of Janet Yellen, as well as recent inflation data that indicate things in the economy could be heating up.

Santelli GIF 1
CNBC via @dorseyshaw

The New Yorker profile not only discusses Janet Yellen's training, but also her broader intellectual and political background. This seems to have really made Santelli unhappy. At one point, Santelli asks the panel, "Do you want to hear social policy from the head of the biggest central bank?"

Advertisement

Josh Brown then jumps in and kind of starts trolling Santelli, telling him at about the 5:00 mark, that, "This is one of the biggest non-sequitur discussions I think I've ever heard." Brown goes into a discussion of the demographic factors at play in the U.S. economy: an aging population that is expected to live longer than ever that would never want to buy bonds to save for retirement.

Santelli then talks about millennials living in basements.

Brown fires back: "How does monetary policy, again, address the problem of millennials that don't have skills for the job marketplace? Explain it to me."

Santelli 1
CNBC

Liesman then steps back in and adds that, "If I concede every point Rick makes, he still cannot explain to me how higher interest rates brings about economic outcomes."

Advertisement

Santelli's response: "Because if I'm a bank, why would I lend to some person at a sub risk-reward rate just because the government subsidizes it so they can do it?"

The whole blowup, which is not Santelli's first and certainly not his last, essentially comes down to Santelli disagreeing with the Fed's policy because it doesn't allow markets to determine the direction of the economy.

Santelli GIF 2
CNBC via @dorseyshaw

In the New Yorker profile, Yellen said, "But the financial crisis really diminished the prestige of those who think that financial market are always efficient and work extremely well." At the outset of the Fed's decision to cut rates, and subsequently engage in large scale asset purchases at various points over the last five years, many including Santelli believed that the Fed's policies would lead to rampant inflation, among other adverse outcomes.

This has not been the case.

Advertisement

Josh Brown later tells Santelli that, "Rick, you already decided [the Fed's policy] wasn't gonna work five years ago."

Santelli's response? "AND I WAS RIGHT! END OF CONVERSATION!" Santelli then walks off.

Santelli 2
CNBC

But then Santelli comes back to yell some more.

And finally, Liesman chimes in for his last word: "It's impossible for you to have been more wrong, Rick. Your call for inflation, the destruction of the dollar, the failure of the U.S. economy to rebound. Rick, it's impossible for you to have been more wrong. Every single bit of advice you gave would've lost people money, Rick."

Advertisement

Ouch.

Watch the whole thing below, it's pretty great.

Federal Reserve
Advertisement
Close icon Two crossed lines that form an 'X'. It indicates a way to close an interaction, or dismiss a notification.

Jump to

  1. Main content
  2. Search
  3. Account